Announcement on Reply to the Letter of Concern of Shenzhen Stock Exchange
Time:2021-09-24
Classification: Company Announcement
Shouhang High-tech Energy Technology Co., Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as "the company" or "Shouhang High-tech") received the "Letter of Concern to Shouhang High-tech Energy Technology Co., Ltd." (Company Department Concern Letter [2021] No. 321) (hereinafter referred to as "Letter of Concern") issued by the Second Department of Management of Listed Companies of Shenzhen Stock Exchange on September 10, 2021, the company disclosed the "Announcement on the Acquisition of 100 Equity of Beijing Juxing Xinneng Technology Co., Ltd." The company intends to purchase 100 equity of Beijing Juxing Xinneng Technology Co., Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as "Juxing Xinneng") for 94.5133 million yuan. The net assets of Juxing Xinneng at the end of the first quarter of 2021 are -70.4108 million yuan."
The second management department of listed companies on the Shenzhen Stock Exchange expressed concern about this and asked the company to verify and make written explanations on the following matters:
1. the purpose of this acquisition is because Juxing Xinneng has the required factory site and office facilities, after the completion of the acquisition, your company's research and development department personnel will be relocated to Juxing Xinneng office, and North China Electric Power University research and development personnel jointly responsible for research and development work. The No. 1 and No. 2 buildings in the property under the name of Juxing Xinneng have been mortgaged to a third party. At present, it has been basically determined that the creditor will apply to the court for debt repayment. The net book value of the aforementioned property is 113.5623 million yuan, and the assessed value is 297.9083 million yuan. Please add your company:
(1) The Board of Directors is requested to express a clear opinion on the fairness of the appraisal results of the main uses of the 1 and 2 buildings, the appraisal methodology, the appraisal assumptions, the selection of parameters, the appraisal process and the reasonableness of the appraisal value added.
Reply: I. Basic Information of Juxing Xineng Real Estate:
Juxing Xinneng holds 7 commercial real estate buildings from Building 1 to Building 7, Yard 20, Dingsi Road, Changping District, Beijing, with a construction area of 22,109.42 ㎡ and a parcel area of 192,922.23 ㎡. The real estate certificate numbers of the 7 buildings are Beijing (2017) Chang Real Estate Rights No. 0038194, 0038846, 0038114, 0038186, 0038144, 0037908 and 0038133 respectively. Right type: state-owned construction land use right/house ownership. Nature of rights: transfer/commercial housing. Use: commercial, occupied land for sale.
The commercial real estate is ultra-low density, low floor area ratio real estate, a single house, is a rare and scarce resource in the suburbs of Beijing. Dingsi Road in front of the door is undergoing reconstruction and expansion. After the reconstruction and expansion, Dingsi Road will be built into a two-way 6-lane urban trunk road with a speed of 60 kilometers per hour. The west is adjacent to the subway Changping line and the regional main road Huichang East Road (two-way 6 lanes), and close to the intersection of Dingsi Road and Huichang East Road. The convenience of travel will be greatly improved in the future.
With the improvement of transportation and other infrastructure, the surrounding areas will increase development efforts and form a new development pattern integrating residence, industrial development, office and commerce, there are educational resources such as Beijing Agricultural College and North China Electric Power College, as well as high-quality educational resources and educational industry bases such as China University of Mining, Beijing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Beijing University of Posts and Telecommunications, Central University of Finance and Economics, Beijing Normal University, and Foreign Affairs University in Changping Shahe Higher Education Park. In terms of industrial development, Xiaomi Smart Industry Demonstration Base (with a total construction area of 231000 ㎡); at present, a number of complex projects such as Tencent Zhongchuang Space, TBD Gathering Center, Singularity Center and Longyu Center have been built, and the development of the region can be expected in the future.
Buildings 3, 4, 5 and 6 of the property held by Juxing Xinneng are rented to education companies as training bases, while buildings 1, 2 and 7 have not been rented and used yet.
Except for No. 1 and No. 2, which are in the state of providing mortgage guarantee, the mortgage status of the remaining No. 3, No. 4, No. 5, No. 6 and No. 7 buildings has been fully released on September 6, 2021, and there are no defects in rights such as mortgage.
II. The assumptions used in the analysis and estimation of the assessment report are as follows:
(I) Basic assumptions
1. Open market assumptions, I .e., the assumption that assets traded in the market or assets to be traded in the market, the two parties to the asset transaction are on an equal footing with each other and have access to sufficient market information and time to make rational judgments about the function, purpose and transaction price of the assets;
2. Trading assumptions, I .e., assuming that all assets to be appraised are already in the process of trading, the appraiser will value the assets to be appraised based on the trading conditions of the assets to be appraised and other simulated markets. Transaction hypothesis is one of the most basic presuppositions for asset valuation;
3. The going concern assumption, I .e., it is assumed that the appraised entity will not cease business for various reasons in the foreseeable future based on existing assets and resource conditions, but will continue to operate legally and continuously.
(ii) General assumptions
1. Assuming that there are no significant changes in the current relevant laws, regulations and policies of the country, the country's macroeconomic situation, and no significant changes in the political, economic and social environment of the regions in which the parties to the transaction are located;
2. Assume that the business is a going concern for the actual condition of the assets at the valuation date;
3. It is assumed that interest rates, exchange rates, tax bases and rates, policy levies, etc. related to the appraised entity will not change materially after the appraisal base date;
4. Assume that the management of the appraised unit is responsible, stable and capable of assuming its duties after the valuation date;
5. Unless otherwise stated, it is assumed that the Company is in full compliance with all relevant laws and regulations;
6. The company can continue to use the existing assets and will not bear any expenses arising from changes in the ownership of the assets and the restructuring plan in the future;
7. It is assumed that the values of the parameters measured in this assessment are determined in accordance with the current price system and do not take into account the effects of inflation after the base date;
8. Assuming that no force majeure and unforeseen factors have a material adverse effect on the appraised entity after the appraisal base date;
9. Assume that the general information, property rights information, policy documents and other relevant materials provided by the client and the asset appraisal unit about the operation of the enterprise are true and valid;
10. It is assumed that the acquisition, acquisition and construction of the assets involved in the subject of appraisal are in compliance with relevant national laws and regulations;
11. It is assumed that the physical assets involved in the appraisal are free of significant technical failures affecting their continued use, and that there are no potential significant quality defects in their key components and materials.
(iii) Special assumptions
1. It is assumed that the accounting policies adopted by the appraised entity after the valuation date are materially consistent with those adopted in the preparation of this asset valuation report;
2. It is assumed that the business scope and mode of the appraised entity after the base date of the appraisal are consistent with the current management mode and management level on the basis of the existing management mode and management level;
III. Selection of assessment methods and main parameters:
In the evaluation, the evaluation agency fully considered the economic development prospects of Beijing, Beijing commercial real estate prospects and other macro factors, while focusing on the development prospects of the region, the surrounding commercial real estate rental income. The final decision was made to use the income approach and the cost approach. Due to the large scale of the commercial real estate, which is a scarce real estate, similar real estate market transaction cases are not available in the region, so the market comparison method is not used.
(I) Main parameters calculated using the income approach:
1, rent, based on the existing lease contract rent, while taking into account the surrounding close to the grade of commercial real estate rental prices, rent is determined to be 3.90/㎡, days, the future annual rental growth rate of 1.5 per cent.
2. Financial risk factor and rate of return: The financial risk factor is determined to be 1.2 per cent and the rate of return is 5.70 per cent.
3. The net income that can be obtained from the resale of real estate held to the end of the period is calculated at an average annual growth rate of 1.8 per cent. The final valuation calculated using the income approach is $438.471 million.
(ii) The main parameters calculated with the present invention are shown in the following table:
| Commercial real estate replacement cost calculation table. | ||||
| Name | Unit price (CNY/㎡) | Rate or Unit Fee Amount | Description | |
| land acquisition cost | 87,719.35 | Land acquisition cost divided by commercial real estate floor area | ||
| Development costs | Construction and installation costs | 3,000.00 | Including civil engineering costs, installation costs, decoration and decoration costs, including tax. | |
| Upfront and other expenses | 173.70 | 5.79% | x% of construction and installation costs (generally 5%-8%) | |
| Supporting fees for public facilities | 450.00 | 15.00% | X% of the construction and installation cost (including the construction cost of public supporting facilities such as water supply and drainage system, gas system, heating system, fire fighting system, fresh air system, etc.) (generally 10-15%) | |
| Urban infrastructure construction fee | -- | -- | If the land use right obtained by way of paid transfer and the land price contains the urban infrastructure construction fee, it shall no longer be levied. | |
| Total | 3,623.70 | |||
| Management expenses | 36.90 | 1.23% | x% of development cost | |
| Selling expenses | 90.00 | 3% | x% of the sum of development costs and management costs (generally 2-4%) | |
| Investment Interest | Including: interest on investment in housing and buildings | 178.15 | 4.75% | Interest is charged on the basis of the sum of the first three items and the two-year loan rate is determined at the base rate of 4.75 per cent, assuming that funds are evenly invested. |
| Land investment interest | 8,333.34 | |||
| Development profit | Including: profit from housing and building development | 504.92 | 15.00% | At present, the average annual direct cost profit margin of real estate development enterprises is about 10-20%. |
| profit of land development | 13,157.90 | 15.00% | ||
| Sales tax | Including: house building sales tax | 97.99 | 9.13% | Including value-added tax, urban construction tax and education surcharge, stamp duty, at 9.13 per cent of the replacement cost price of the house. |
| Land partial sales tax | 8,008.78 | 9.13% | ||
| Unit price of replacement cost of housing and buildings (excluding VAT) | 3,921.21 | |||
| Unit price of replacement cost of commercial real estate (excluding VAT) | 111,461.91 | |||
Due to the large land area of the plot, the final evaluation value calculated by cost method is 2221.7211 million yuan. At present, the utilization rate and profitability of Juxing's new energy assets are not high, but considering that the development of the region is accelerating, the future development potential and development prospects are good. Moreover, the commercial land price in Beijing has been rising continuously in recent years. According to the dynamic monitoring data of urban land price in Beijing, the commercial land price in Beijing increased by 37.71 from the first quarter of 2014 to the first quarter of 2021. The influence of land appreciation factors cannot be ignored when determining the assessed value of the commercial real estate. The future income of the assets assessed by the income method is based on the principle of prudence, according to the current rent level and the impact of the new coronavirus on the commercial real estate, in addition, the possible growth rate in the future is considered for prediction, and the result of income method has great uncertainty; the evaluation result of cost method reflects the cost payable for obtaining the appraised assets on the base date of evaluation. As the appraised assets are villa commercial real estate, the price level of commercial land is relatively high, which leads to the evaluation result of cost method far higher than that of income method; if the evaluation result of income method is adopted, the appraised assets may be underestimated, if the cost method is adopted, the evaluation results cannot reflect the economic depreciation factors caused by the low utilization rate and profitability of the appraised assets. Therefore, considering the above factors comprehensively, the weighted average method is adopted to determine the final evaluation value of the appraised commercial real estate for the evaluation results of the income method and the cost method. The weight of the appraisal results of the income method is 90%, and the weight of the appraisal results of the cost method is 10%.
Evaluation value of investment real estate = evaluation value of income method × 90% + evaluation value of cost method × 10% = 43,847.10 × 90%+222,172.11 × 10%= 616.7962 million yuan
The total construction area of the property is 22,109.42 ㎡, with an average valuation of 27900 yuan/㎡, and the overall valuation is reasonable and fair.
(iii) Opinion of the Board of Directors:
In accordance with the provisions of the Rules Governing the Listing of Stocks on the Shenzhen Stock Exchange and other regulations and normative documents, the Board of Directors of the Company makes the following comments on the independence of the appraisal body, the basis and method of appraisal, the reasonableness of the assumptions and the fairness of the appraisal pricing on the equity acquisition:
The asset appraisal agency of this transaction, Beijing Guorong Xinghua Asset Appraisal Co., Ltd., is qualified for asset appraisal of securities business. Except for the business relationship of this transaction, the appraisal agency and the parties to this transaction have no other related relationship, and there are no real and expected interests or conflicts, and they are independent. We are concerned about the asset-based method adopted in this appraisal and the selection of appraisal assumptions, as well as the selection of appraisal parameters and the relationship between relevant indicators and appraisal conclusions. The Board of Directors believes that the assumptions and the selection of appraisal methods in the appraisal report can be implemented in accordance with relevant national laws and regulations, follow common practices or standards in the market, and conform to the actual situation of the appraisal object; the choice of assessment methods, the relationship between relevant indicators and assessment conclusions are logical. The appraisal agency has implemented appropriate appraisal procedures in the appraisal process, following the principles of independence, objectivity and impartiality, with appropriate appraisal methods and fair appraisal results.
(2) The specific circumstances of the mortgage on the properties of Building 1 and Building 2, including, but not limited to, the amount of the mortgage loan, the term of the loan, the pledgee, the debtor, and the specific progress of the debt repayment currently being executed by the court.
Reply: On September 12, 2017, Juxing Xinneng and China Resources Shenguo Investment Trust Co., Ltd. signed a real estate mortgage agreement, contract number: China Resources Trust Zengli No. 40 Single Fund Trust Real Estate Mortgage Agreement 2017-1501-BDCDY01. In view of the fact that Beijing Shouhang Bellows Manufacturing Co., Ltd., Huang Wenjia and Wang Sumei (hereinafter referred to as the "Debtor") and China Resources Shenzhen Investment Trust Co., Ltd. have signed the "China Resources Trust • Zengli No. 40 Single Fund Trust Credit Enhancement Agreement" (hereinafter referred to as the "Master Contract") numbered 2017-[1501]-XYZJ01, Juxing Xinneng agrees to provide mortgage guarantee for the debtor's obligations under the main contract, the debts guaranteed are the additional enhanced trust funds agreed in the main contract and the amount of payment for the difference, as well as all the obligations, liabilities, liabilities and related expenses under the main contract, such as liquidated damages, damages, expenses for realizing creditor's rights and security rights, etc., and the mortgage amount is four hundred and fifty million yuan only, the collateral is 101 on floors 1-3 and 101 on floors 1-2 and building 2-1-2 of courtyard 20, dingsi road, Changping district, Beijing. the real estate certificate numbers are Beijing (2017) chang real estate rights no 0038194 and no 0038846 respectively, with a construction area of 7781.4 ㎡ and 2542.67 ㎡ respectively, and the amount of the collateral is 301.5 million yuan only, the mortgage period is from September 12, 2017 to March 18, 2022.
According to the current situation, the debtor owes creditors about 0.4 billion yuan. Because the debtor failed to perform the debt, the lawyer entrusted by the creditor sent a letter to the debtor in February 2021, demanding that the repayment obligation be fulfilled, otherwise the debtor and the mortgagee will be judicially claimed. Although the debtor has repeatedly communicated with creditors in the hope that the debt will be extended. But so far, no extension agreement has been signed, and creditors have not yet sued. However, because the facts of the dispute are relatively clear and simple, once legal proceedings are entered, it is expected that the disposal of the mortgaged property will be implemented soon.
(3) The specific requirements of the research and development work on the factory site and office facilities, and whether there are other real estate under the name of Juxing Xinneng. If so, please supplement and disclose the name, location, use, area, property right certificate, etc. of the relevant real estate, and whether it can meet the needs of the research and development work; If no, can your company's acquisition purpose be realized if buildings 1 and 2 are repaid by the court.
Answer: See the above reply for the details of all the properties of Juxing Xinneng. At present, Juxing Xinneng Building 1, Building 2 and Building 7 are idle. Shouhang Gaoke will give priority to using the area of 1,935.32 ㎡ of Building 7 to carry out research and development work. The specific area required for research and development work, etc., still need to be determined according to the number of specific research and development projects gradually signed by the company and North China Electric Power University.
Although there is a high probability that buildings 1 and 2 will be executed by the court, it will take some time. Before that, the area of 10,324.07 ㎡ of buildings 1 and 2 can still be used. If there are more research and development projects in the future, the company may consider taking back some of the rental properties for research and development, so the implementation of buildings 1 and 2 will not affect the realization of the company's acquisition purpose.
Second, Juxing Xinneng 100 equity valuation of 278.8593 million yuan, the end of the first quarter of 2021 net assets of -70.4108 million yuan, mainly due to the provision of 1 and 2 buildings estimated liabilities of 113.5623 million yuan. Your company claims that this transaction does not harm the interests of the company and shareholders. Your company added:
(1) The specific methodology, significant assumptions, specific processes, key parameters and the basis and reasonableness of the relevant assumptions and parameters of the Juxing New Energy Assessment, as well as the specific reasons for and fairness of the assessment value added.
Answer: According to the audit report, the total assets of Juxing Xinneng on the statement date were 306.8564 million yuan, of which the amount of investment real estate was 267.5261 million yuan, accounting for 87.18 percent, and the main assets of Juxing Xinneng were investment real estate.
In the appraisal, except for the appreciation of investment real estate, there was no change in the value of other assets and liabilities, and the appraisal of investment real estate is detailed above.
(2) The specific reasons for the estimated liabilities of Building 1 and Building 2, the specific basis and adequacy of your company's judgment not to harm the interests of the company and shareholders.
Answer: Please refer to the above for details of the mortgage of Building 1 and Building 2. During the evaluation, the company has deducted the value of Building 1 and Building 2 considering the mortgage of Building 1 and Building 2. As the debtor is involved in a number of large amounts of debt disputes, there is no recovery in repayment capacity. Out of prudence, the company requires that the estimated liabilities be accrued in the acquisition of equity, and the value of buildings 1 and 2 shall not be included in the amount of equity transaction, so as to safeguard the legitimate rights and interests of the company. The subject company's estimated liability for this risky asset is charged, and the value of high-risk assets is excluded from the equity transaction amount, effectively safeguarding the interests of the company and shareholders.
The net assets of Juxing Xinneng are -70.4109 million yuan, mainly due to the estimated liabilities of 113.5623 million yuan for buildings 1 and 2. The appraised value of Juxing Xinneng's equity is 278.8593 million yuan. The difference between the two is due to the appraised value of the real estate owned by Juxing Xinneng, and the appraised value of the equity includes the appraised value of Building 1 and Building 2 (except for investment real estate, other assets and liabilities in the equity appraisal are based on the audit report, so the accrued estimated liabilities are also considered at the same time. After the estimated liabilities are accrued in the audit report, net assets no longer include the net value of buildings 1 and 2).
Subsequent to the existence of mortgage guarantees in buildings 1 and 2, there may be a greater probability of being executed by the court. The mortgage status of the remaining buildings 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7 has been fully released on September 6, 2021, with no risk of disposal.
3. The 100 equity of Juxing Xinneng is priced at 94.5133 million yuan. Your company will pay 47.2567 million yuan to the counterparty within 5 working days after signing the acquisition agreement, and the remaining equity transfer amount will be paid within 10 working days after the completion of Juxing Xinneng equity transfer registration. Your company's 2021 semi-annual report shows a monetary fund balance of $676.6406 million and a short-term loan balance of $1,575.7281 million. Please add your company:
(1) Combined with available monetary funds and short-term debt repayment arrangements, explain whether the acquisition may cause greater pressure on your company's cash flow, and fully alert the relevant risks.
Answer: As of June 31, 2021, the company's total liabilities are 2283.6378 million yuan, total assets are 7,970.4069 million yuan, the asset-liability ratio is 28.65, and the company's asset-liability ratio index is good.
From the comparison of monetary funds and short-term borrowing, the company does have some debt service pressure. However, considering the company's bills receivable, accounts receivable and normal repayment ability, the unmortgaged property of Juxing Xinneng can also be used to mortgage loans, and the funds used for the acquisition of Juxing Xinneng as a whole do not affect the company's original production and operation work.
The Company's short-term borrowings were mainly $1,250 million from Xiamen International Bank, for which the Company provided sufficient collateral to repay the interest on time. The company has a good relationship with the bank and expects the loan to continue to be renewed.
(2) Self-check whether there is any relationship between the counterparty of this transaction and your company's major shareholders and directors and supervisors, and whether there is any transfer of benefits.
Answer: According to the relevant provisions of the Shenzhen Stock Exchange Stock Listing Rules, we have compared the terms of the rules one by one, and believe that the counterparty of this transaction does not meet the prescribed conditions for related legal persons and related natural persons. There is no related relationship.
In view of the fact that Huang Qingmei, the legal representative of Juxing Xineng, and Huang Wenjia, the legal person of the company, are uncles and nephews at the time of the transaction, after receiving this letter of concern, we have discussed and communicated with lawyers and other professionals on this issue. Some professionals believe that whether the relationship between uncles and nephews is characterized as a related relationship is relatively vague. Furthermore, Juxing Xineng provided mortgage guarantee for Beijing Shouhang Bellows Manufacturing Co., Ltd., Huang Wenjia and Wang Sumei. Based on prudent consideration, the lawyer suggested that the company convene a board of directors to confirm this transaction in the procedure of related transactions, the company from a prudent point of view decided to adopt this proposal, decided to convene a board of directors to confirm, the amount of the matter has not yet reached the standard of the general meeting of shareholders, by the board of directors to consider and confirm. The company will suspend the acquisition process until it is approved by the board of directors.
4. Other matters that your company should explain.
Answer: 1. The main purpose of this acquisition of Juxing New Energy is to provide research and development sites for the company and North China Electric Power University to jointly develop solar thermal power generation technology, new energy materials, energy storage technology and applications and other related technologies, and to relocate employees of the company's R & D department Provide office space and business premises.
2. Before the Board of Directors of the Company considers and confirms the procedures for this transaction, the Company confirms that the relevant lease contract for the existence of the acquired assets has been terminated. At the same time, the company promises that all the assets acquired in this transaction will be used for the company's office operation and self-use, and will not be used for commercial real estate development and operation in the future.
It is hereby announced.
Shouhang Gaoke Energy Technology Co., Ltd.
Board of Directors
September 23, 2021